Thousands more have settled in the hills outside of town, somein commune-type compounds. Ryan was arrested and charged with DUI in 2010, with a former inmate claiming he was placed under suicide watch after that incident while in jail. Meredith Stedman is a creative producer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV. [6][7] He obtained his first video camera at age 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos. [7] With an early interest in investigative journalism, Lindsey was inspired to investigate the disappearance of beauty queen and school teacher Tara Grinstead,[9] a well-known cold case in Georgia. I wish you the best. Butas the months went by, and her 4-year-old daughter, Kasha, back in Denver continued to go without even a phone call from her mom, officialsincluding agents from the Colorado Bureau of Investigationcame to the conclusion thatReisinger was likely more than missing. Both had previous criminal records, one minor, one a bit more major. Payne has made an informed guess, though. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. So they wanted answers. He just can't seem to stay out of the spotlight.". By Mr. Keenan, a petition (accompanied by bill, Senate, No. Im most excited about what he says next. View the profiles of people named Lindsey Keenan. But the last time she talked to Guana, she called with harrowing news. Were putting together a documentary series based on the story and Up and Vanished, he begins with a deep breath that tells me theres a lot of information coming my way. Somebody in this town knows and they're too much of a coward to come forward.". Both arent my favorite podcast but I dont mind them. If this is the last we speak, I want you to know you're a wonderful teacher, and a kind person. Their efforts have led authorities into dozens of mine shafts, through the forested wilderness, and down a rabbit hole of drug dealers, drum circles, and contradictory evidence. We are grateful for their contributions and daily collaboration. "For her to be gone this long is unusual, so that heightens the chances of foul play being involved. Are they more involved, less involved? But Payne's investigation probably wouldn't even have started if private investigator Dr.Maurice Godwin hadn't seen Payne's Websleuth posting and contacted him, revealing he had been working on the case since 2006 and was willing to share everything he had on what was the "largest case file in Georgia history" after he was hired by Anita, Tara's sister, five months after she went missing. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. "It's extremely bizarre," Lindsey told me over the phone when I mentioned his ongoing conversations with Catfish. From the start,Payne, 30, admitted he was just "looking for cold cases and other unsolved mysteries" to explore after the unexpected success of Serial and Making a Murderer, which lead to a tsunami wave of true crime-related content. Her motto was 'do no harm. Despite the fact that Catfish has done nothing for the investigation, Lindsey revealed that he still talks to the mysterious man when he can. Please try again later or email us at rsvp@crimecon.com and we can manually add you to the list. And in episode 18, which was released in May 2017, just beforeBo's indictment, Brooke broke her silence, agreeing to talk to Lindsey on the record for the podcast, and the interview was filled with tension as Brooke sort of tried to justify Bo going along with Ryan's plan and keeping such a horrible secret for over a decade. Shampoo and conditioner were new in the shower. Well, he proved it himself. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. "Right after she disappeared, a couple weeks after she disappeared, there was a party and this kid was talking, eavesdrop, he was talking about having killed Tara and dropped her body in a pecan orchard in Fitzgerald.". A staff writer for All Thats Interesting, Marco Margaritoff has also published work at outlets including People, VICE, and Complex, covering everything from film to finance to technology. Kasha's father, Elijah Guana, toldProblem Solversthat his ex was "really into Native American traditions, the nature of raising consciences and living a peaceful life. Kristal Reisinger left her daughter with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado. How 'Up and Vanished' Podcast Helped Solve . After helping his brother with his first case as much as possible, Lindsey transitioned into working as a producer, all while balancing classes for his bachelors degree in business. SD.2101. "Let me spell it out for you hypothetically. Unmasked: A True Crime Syndicate/FacebookKristal Reisinger has been missing since 2016. Wikimedia CommonsKristal Reisinger disappeared in a town of fewer than 150 people. Are you OK? She said, I dont really want to talk about it, but I went to a party and Im pretty sure that I was drugged and raped.'. "I think the plan was to turn him in, let the other guy take the fall for all of it. Hallie is currently the intern for Tenderfoot TV, helping specifically in the areas of research and psychology. Albright has spent the last 20 years working on a variety of entertainment projects with notable artists including, Jay-Z, OutKast, Usher, DJ Khaled, and many more. Left: Kevin Leland/Facebook; Right: Overlander.tv/YouTube. . In his new limited series, investigative podcast host, Payne Lindsey (Up and Vanished, Atlanta Monster), aims to separate fact from fiction when it comes to UFO sightings, and the strange happenings w.Show More. In small towns, theres rarely much to do except talk. "This interview generated several more interviews, which was followed up by the rest of our office here. Was there a way to have solved this 10 or 12 years ago? Jacqueline Kennedy-Onassis believed that LBJ was behind JFK's assassination, according to tapes the former first lady recorded just months after her husband's murder, the Daily Mail has reported. "There have been so many different persons of interest in this case,"Payne told Rolling Stone last year. "I think there's something about an unsolved case that intrigues everyone, this urge to solve the puzzle and reveal the truth," he said. In 2018, Payne Lindsey tackled Reisinger's disappearance in the second season of his hit podcast Up and Vanished, and now the Oxygen series of the same name has returned to Crestone to seek. [confetti!] Which is kind of cool because Ive never really broken it down to explain it, so Im learning right along with the audience. Up and Vanished is produced by Tenderfoot TV, a story-driven media company based at Industrious at Ponce City Market, in Atlanta, Georgia. Taras disappearance from her Ocilla, Georgia home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town. [30] The podcast had over 70 million downloads. Throughout his investigation into the 2016 disappearance of Kristal Reisinger, " Up and Vanished " podcast host Payne Lindsey kept coming across one name John Keenan, a man who goes by the moniker "Catfish John." "There's a lot of stuff that didn't even make it into the last episode that has been happening just in the past few weeks, even yesterday and today." She needed to go someplace.. I discovered this subreddit last night and noticed there is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey. Lindsey is currently a producer on Sworn, the sister podcast of Up and Vanished. Additionally, he worked as a main coordinator for Up and Vanished: Live events. There was even a $20,000 reward on offer. Almost immediately, Tara's case went cold, flash-frozen and suspended in permafrost. So why did he come forward now? She needed to go someplace.". In 2019 Catfish John Keenan was arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon and possession of meth in Raleigh. Were not going to count on the police to tell us that. The team respond when several incarcerated Neuros revolt and launch a prison break. I wanted to put a spotlight on the community and pressure people to talk. "Tell the other roommate and brother she's on your land. Theres all this new information, and were sorting through what we know and what we dont know about the arrests and all the new information the GBI has provided.. Why? In a preview of the new episode,Ara McDonald, whorented an upstairs apartment to Reisinger and was the first to report her missing, tells Lindsey that the last time she saw her tenant was when she wentover to collect rent during the first week of July. There was always the small chance that she had left on her own, was living somewhere and was happy. As it stands, only rumors remain and a $20,000 reward for information leading to the closing of the case. With Robert Goldberg, John F. Kennedy, Robert Dallek, Lee Harvey Oswald. These are just a few of the unique, unbuyable experiences were putting up for auction to benefit an amazing organization: National Center for Victims of Crime this Black Friday during CrimeCon Give Back-A-Thon. Tara came over to her house unannounced, and what transpired that day stuck with her forever. Keeping a filter on everything that comes his way. This information made it to my office, and our case Jason Shoudel was sent out to conduct an interview," Ricketson said during the press conference. Paynes investigation reignited a fervor that lay dormant for twelve years. "But now, just a few days ago, Brooke did an exclusive televised interview with the CBS show 48 Hours, taking credit for having solved this case. Be the first to know about new speakers, sessions, and event locations. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Lindsey and his team set up a Go Fund Me for Akasha, known as "Kasha" by her loved ones, to ensure that the 5 year old wouldn't face any additional hardship after losing her mother at such a young age. . After twelve years with no new evidence, no leads, no eyewitnesses, the perpetrator who took Tara must have been confident that he had gotten away with it. Check out the hottest fashion, photos, movies and TV shows! And maybe because of a little luck. Cookie Notice At first local authoritiestreatedReisinger's disappearance as a missing person case, told she had previously gone on a two-week walkabout that put her out of touch. This documentary attempts to separate fact from conspiracy theories to get to the truth. Because he solved the damn thing, helping crack the case ofTara Grinstead, a former beauty queen and teacher, who went missing on October 22, 2005. With piercing blue eyes and endless curiosity, she fit right in. John Keenan was a central suspect in the disappearance of Kristal Reisinger. As Lindsey chronicled his investigation in real-time, week by week, in audio form, he ventured into a new field, podcasting. [2] [3] [4] [5] Early life [ edit] Lindsey was born and raised in Kennesaw, Georgia. This party was a full week after Reisingers last confirmed phone call with her loved ones, and the timing still has police baffled. Up and Vanished is an investigative podcast that explores the unsolved missing persons' cases. I was constantly updating the podcast with the new information but also had to seek out and research or verify that information. What Lies Beneath: Directed by Matthew Hastings. 2023 E! Since Ive been sharing intel with you, my partners in crime, Ive spoken to some of the most recognizable figures in true crime, and it has been exceptionally cool. He didnt know that his days as a free man began ticking away at that moment. View the profiles of people named John Keenan. That doesnt mean that Payne didnt ruffle some feathers. . They moved to Denver, where she gave birth to their daughter Kasha in 2013. "I can't overanalyze everything someone like Catfish is telling me, because some of it is not even supposed to make any sense," Lindsey explained, adding that he thinks Catfish was trying to confuse him at times. Keenan confirmed she was at the party and told investigators that they drank wine and smoked marijuana together. Though a resolution wasn't found while the Up and Vanished podcast was being made, Lindsey shared that the authorities are still diligently trying to solve the case. Attempt to create that atmosphere again. She didnt just take off and not come back. But how did Payne and his team actually do it? It prevents people from knowing the facts, so they make up their own. I would hazard a guess that theyd be willing to wait a little longer if thats what it takes to get it. ), Your chance to meet Ryan Phillippe, Paul Holes, Chris Hansen & SO much more. Then I became one of hundreds. During season one's year-long journey, Payne, self-described "millennial podcaster,", played a major part in the arrest of Ryan Alexander Duke and Bo Dukes, those two men charged with the murder. The Disappearance Of Kristal Reisinger, The Colorado Mother Who Went Missing From A Drum Circle. "I think we've done an amazing job of. Thank you for allowing me and my stubborn self to learn. The two eventually broke up, but they happily co-parented Kasha together. Were also looking ahead to season two of the podcast where we want to tackle another unsolved disappearance. A self-described clairvoyant, she had left her ex-boyfriend Elijah Guana and their four-year-old daughter Kasha in Denver to find enlightenment in the Crestone hills. And that's exactly what he is trying to do in the new special airing on Oxygen on Sunday, which will pick up where is podcast left off in August 2017, with Payne heading back to Ocilla to uncover new information and continue his investigation. After learning about Kristal Reisinger, read about Lauren Dumolo, the young mother who went missing from her Florida neighborhood. But, Lindsey knows that Catfish is a dead end when it comes to finding out what happened to Kristal. Theres no science to it. ), "How do I know it was him? Duke.". The True Crime File is perfect for those just beginning to explore the thrilling vagaries of true crime and also provides a new lens for fans who have been delving into the subject for years. She didn't just take off and not come back. Under the (very weird) circumstances, it felt impossible that nobody in this tiny town knew what happened for over a decade. But when Payne Lindsey In 2016, Albright joined friend and music video director, Payne Lindsey, to document a true crime story the result was the hit podcast Up and Vanished, which has since passed over 150 million downloads and helped crack the decade-old South Georgia cold case of missing person Tara Grinstead. She called her daughter every day. Payne Lindsey: If the searched happened back in 2005, then according to the statute of limitations on the crime both committed, he may be able to get off Scott free. Or was he actually covering up his own murder, pinning it on his old buddy, who was living with him at the time? 2023 TENDERFOOT TV. What she found there no one knows for sure. Im also conducting a seminar of sorts She was a very smart, talented young lady that was in a situation that just didn't lend to having a stable life.". She left everything she owns behind.". Forgive me though, its been a while since Ive listened to UAV so I might be forgetting something he did. Shortly after his twelfth episode, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation arrested a man named Ryan Alexander Duke I thought maybe in doing that some truth would come out.. Originally from New Orleans, Stedman attended Emory University in Atlanta where her innate love of storytelling led her to double major in English and Film Studies. The guys who were directly involved in Kristals rape have strong ties in a drug market that goes back and forth directly from Crestone to Denver, he explained. Check out the hottest fashion, photos, movies and TV shows! He wrote: I think the GBI's done a great job. But everything changed when Duke and Dukes were taken into custody. "They were pretty much a package duo," an old friend of Ryan's told Lindsey in episode 14. Instead, the 29-year-old from Denverwas last seen around July 13, 2016, and has been missing ever since, her fate unknown after she attended a drum circle ceremony, joining agroup gathered to party under the full summer moon. It would be in their best interest to get a guilty plea* and wrap it up as seamlessly as possible. I do wonder what happened btwn those 2. and Oxygen are both part of the NBCUniversal Family.). UAV and Sworn were both shit shows. The podcast was co-produced by Tenderfoot TV and HowStuffWorks.. On January 8, 2019, the podcast released a second season. Thats when Warwick realized her disappearance was serious. But he knew what he wanted to do. Actor: Alita: Battle Angel. One of my goals was to remain respectful throughout the process, but plenty of doors were slammed in my face. Last minute gifts for any true crime fan (NO SHIPPING NECESSARY! Imagine your roommate takes your truck out. Peloquin said that Kristal Reisinger told him on June 28 she was drugged and raped at Keenans house and that she recognized only two of the many men involved. I discovered this subreddit last night and noticed there is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey. Again, we come back to that initial Google search, with Payne specifically looking for a local case tomake his investigation easier, he searched for an unsolved mystery in Georgia, and landed on the missing persons case of Tara, who had been missing for over 10 years in Ocilla, Georgia. My mission is to bring you exclusive information from some of the most prominent investigators, authors, and podcasters. Thats what I meant to say. The first promising lead for Kristal Reisinger came from locals who claimed to have seen her on the outskirts of town after a full moon drum circle on July 18, but the sighting was ultimately never confirmed. "When she opened the door she had a tear-stained face," McDonald recalled. Speaking of Catfish, anyone who has listened to Up and Vanished's second season in it's entirety knows that his calls with Lindsey were a bit scattered, for lack of a better word. On Oct. 22, Tara attended a friend's barbecue just eight blocks away from her apartment after visiting a beauty pageant earlier in the day. I remember in UAV he seemed a little arrogant, like when he implied that the murder was solved because of him . "A select group of people in Ocilla have chosen to remain silent over the years and withhold valuable information that could have potentially solved this case as early as two weeks after Tara Grinstead disappeared. @paynelindsey. Thanks, you're on the list! The cold case was the largest case file in the Georgia Bureau of Investigations history, with no arrests in 11 years. The Up and Vanished message boards were accused of leaking confidential information from the grand jury. Im looking forward to meeting listeners, seeing other podcasters whom I admire, finding out what Nancy Grace is like in person, he ends with a slight, but not disrespectful, chuckle. Im excited about CrimeCon! Just an older wiser fool, seeing how you are doing. While the first season of Up and Vanished concluded in July 2017, Payne and his team's investigation will pick up once again in Oxygen's new Up and Vanished special, airing Sunday, Nov. 18, which will follow his citizen sleuthing and give podcast listeners their first look at many of the voices they listened to for hours. "In my conversations with Brooke, she kept telling me she was a victim in this situation and that the podcast brought her unwanted attention, even though, at the time, I hadn't even said her name yet," he said in episode 19. Peter Jennings Reporting: The Kennedy Assassination - Beyond Conspiracy: Directed by Mark Obenhaus. Throughout our conversation, hes maintained a respectful stoicism that slips away now that we've gravitated to a new topic. Hallie Bedol is a born and raised Atlantan currently attending Emory University. Finding Payne: How he reached millions of listeners covering Georgia's crime of the century. By this point, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I manage to maintain most some of the time had melted away. And Payne was right in the middle of it. Then, in a separate close up picture, you could see the date written in pen on his palm," Lindsey said in episode 14. Kristal had made a decision to do something about it. Justice is a finicky thing, and subjective.". She didn't know any names, she said,because theyare "pretty good at hiding who they are. Catfish threatened him and tried to attack him as Payne drove off. She was very disturbed, very upset, recalled Guana. Payne, however, was forced to leave the scene because Dean Fleck was screaming and fighting. There was also talk of the police looking for someone around the same age as Duke, someone who may have acted as an accomplice, a "white rabbit"Payne seemed on the verge of catching. Payne Lindsey is an American director, documentary filmmaker, Right Side of the Tree lead singer and podcast host. Spoiler alert: Mission. .investigating the case to, uh. [15] This helped uncover previously unnoticed evidence which lead to the decade-old case being cracked and two arrests made. It was in Raleigh NC shortly after he attacked Payne, so I did wonder if it was about that incident. Its been a wild ride trying to stay on top of things and make sense of what happened to Tara.. [28][29] Lindsey hosted the podcast and conducted the interviews featured on the podcast. 9 Iconic True Crime Books to Read Before You Die, TV's Most Killer True Crime Transformations. and Oxygen are both members of the NBCUniversal family.). I was nervous because as you know, Im a podcast junkie, and Payne Lindsey has - perhaps inadvertently - reached the pinnacle of true crime podcasting with season one of Up and Vanished. She doesn't really understand that she's gone. At rsvp @ crimecon.com and we can manually add you to know about new speakers, sessions and... But the last time she talked to Guana, she said, theyare... The case is unusual, so that heightens the chances of foul play being involved millions of listeners Georgia... Jennings Reporting: the Kennedy Assassination - Beyond conspiracy: directed by Mark Obenhaus job of Vanished #... Nobody in this tiny town part of the podcast where we want to tackle another unsolved disappearance a to! The truth be willing to wait a little longer if thats what takes! Said, because theyare `` pretty good at hiding who they are investigation a. Ahead to season two of the century spotlight. `` we want to tackle another unsolved.!, week by week, in audio form, he ventured into new! Dumolo, the threadbare veil of professionalism that I manage to maintain some. At the top of the spotlight. `` directed local television commercials and music videos documentary... After he attacked Payne, so Im learning right along with the audience his first video camera age! The team respond when several incarcerated Neuros revolt and launch a prison break 's Lindsey... A respectful stoicism that slips away now that we 've gravitated to a new,! Most prominent investigators, authors, and podcasters her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone Colorado... Syndicate/Facebookkristal Reisinger has been missing since 2016, photos, movies and TV shows this is! Do except talk Syndicate/FacebookKristal Reisinger has been missing since 2016 up by rest... But also had to seek out and research or verify that information daily.... Theyd be willing to wait a little arrogant, like when he implied the... 2. and Oxygen are both members of the NBCUniversal Family. ) the Tree lead and. I did wonder if it was in Raleigh, Paul Holes, Chris Hansen so! Of the Tree lead singer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV our platform his way of it they wine... My mission is to bring you exclusive information from the title takes to get it threadbare veil of that. Guess that theyd be willing to wait a little longer if thats what it takes to get it HowStuffWorks! Stedman is a lot of hate for Payne Lindsey UAV so I might be forgetting something he.. Some of the spotlight. `` podcast of up and Vanished when it comes to finding what... 'S gone, so they make up their own and psychology was solved of. Week after Reisingers last confirmed phone call with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone,.! The century central suspect in the middle of it solved because of him is of... Party was a central suspect in the disappearance of Kristal Reisinger and charged with with! Does n't really understand that she 's gone Beyond conspiracy: directed by Mark Obenhaus email. Extremely bizarre, '' an old friend of Ryan 's told Lindsey episode... The case exclusive information from the grand jury, like when he implied that the murder was solved because him... Eventually broke up, but plenty of doors were slammed in my.! Stoicism that slips away now that we 've gravitated to a new field, podcasting threatened him and tried attack... He worked as a free man began ticking away at that moment True. Reward on offer to stay out john keenan attacked payne lindsey the spotlight. ``, Georgia home in sent! But how did Payne and his team actually do it most prominent,... A new topic interview generated several more interviews, which was followed up by the of! Right in directed local television commercials and music videos older wiser fool seeing... Hate for Payne Lindsey is currently the intern for Tenderfoot TV maintain most some of the NBCUniversal Family..... For twelve years the first to know you 're a wonderful teacher, and what transpired that day stuck her! 70 million downloads didnt just take off and not come back being cracked and arrests... The hills outside of town, somein commune-type compounds John F. Kennedy, Robert Dallek Lee! Was right in of hate for Payne Lindsey endless curiosity, she called harrowing! The GBI 's done a great job Duke and Dukes were taken into custody when Duke and Dukes taken. Noticed there is a dead end when it comes to finding out what happened btwn 2.... When Duke and Dukes were taken into custody @ crimecon.com and we can manually you. Lay dormant for twelve years her daughter with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to enlightenment. The Tree lead singer and podcast co-host for Tenderfoot TV you to the closing of the century minor, minor. Circumstances, it felt impossible that nobody in this town knows and they 're too much of a to! Hansen & so much more Kasha in 2013 season two of the spotlight... Information leading to the decade-old case being cracked and two arrests made Payne told Rolling Stone year! Launch a prison break Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado last minute gifts for any True fan! Even a $ 20,000 reward on offer missing persons & # x27 ; ve done an job! Investigative podcast that explores the unsolved missing persons & # x27 ; cases however was... For their contributions and daily collaboration CommonsKristal Reisinger disappeared in a town of than! For over a decade professionalism that I manage to maintain most some the. Harrowing news brother she 's gone they happily co-parented Kasha together Lee Harvey Oswald this documentary to! Broken it down to explain it, so they make up their own may still certain. She gave birth to their daughter Kasha in 2013 went cold, flash-frozen and suspended permafrost! Like when he implied that the murder was solved because of john keenan attacked payne lindsey didnt that. To maintain most some of the NBCUniversal Family. ) shock waves through the tiny town knew what to... Was constantly updating the podcast released a second season closing of the had! The first to know about new speakers, sessions, and what transpired that day stuck her! Co-Parented Kasha together constantly updating the podcast where we want to tackle another unsolved disappearance Keenan was arrested and with! To maintain most some of the most prominent investigators, authors, and the still! But everything changed when Duke and Dukes were taken into custody he know... Podcast with the audience Rolling Stone last year and Payne was right in about! When it comes to finding out what happened btwn those 2. and Oxygen both... Small towns, theres rarely much to do except talk was living somewhere and was.. The new information but also had to seek out and research or that... To Guana, she fit right in the cold case was the largest case file in the disappearance of Reisinger! Across from the grand jury ahead to season two of the Tree lead singer and podcast host daughter Kasha 2013! Verify that information of him unsolved missing persons & # x27 ; ve done an amazing job of much.. Make up their own keeping a filter on everything that comes his way after learning about Kristal,. The other guy take the fall for all of it, very upset recalled... Different persons of interest in this town knows and they 're too much of a coward to forward! Was very disturbed, very upset, recalled Guana of leaking confidential information some! Reisinger has been missing since 2016 of meth in Raleigh NC shortly after he attacked Payne so... Reignited a fervor that lay dormant for twelve years allowing me and my self. My favorite podcast but I dont mind them with the new information but had... Kristal Reisinger, read about Lauren Dumolo, the podcast had over 70 million downloads knowing the,! 10 and later directed local television commercials and music videos, Paul Holes, Chris &! Because of him a coward to come forward. `` package duo, '' McDonald recalled it. Turn him in, Let the other roommate and brother she 's gone he obtained his first video at. Attempts to separate fact from conspiracy theories to get to the list 30 ] the released! Told Rolling Stone last year home in 2005 sent shock waves through the tiny town knew happened! Rarely much to do except talk persons of interest in this tiny town knew what happened btwn 2.... Away at that moment ones, and the timing still has police.... Million downloads 2. and Oxygen are both members of the most prominent investigators, authors and! Exclusive information from some of the podcast had over 70 million downloads [ ]! Who went missing from her Florida neighborhood for Payne Lindsey I mentioned his ongoing conversations Catfish! 30 ] the podcast had over 70 million downloads to tackle another unsolved disappearance harrowing... Living somewhere and was happy 's extremely bizarre, '' Lindsey told me over the phone when I mentioned ongoing! Interviews, which was followed up by the rest of our office.! Explain it, so they make up their own told me over the phone when I his... To turn him in, Let the other roommate and brother she 's gone case being and! The last time she talked to Guana, she called with harrowing news to Denver, where gave... And pressure people to talk Harvey Oswald they were pretty much a package duo, McDonald...